Irregularpedia

Debate: Difference between revisions

VisualWikitext
Initial
 
No edit summary
 
(2 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
<span id="debate-club"></span>
= Debate Club =
= Debate Club =


The goal is to increase the time and attention required to argue positions in the irregularchat community and to provide more structure to discussions which aims to identify agreements in positions and differing perspectives and information gaps.
The purpose of the Debate Club in the Irregularchat community is to create a structured environment for constructive argumentation. This platform is designed to foster thoughtful discussions, highlight areas of agreement, understand differing perspectives and identify information gaps. Members can explore complex topics respectfully and patiently by adhering to structured engagement.


<span id="key-rules-for-engagement"></span>
== Key Rules for Engagement ==
== Key Rules for Engagement: ==


= Civility First: Always maintain a respectful and good faith tone. =
'''Civility First''': Always maintain a respectful tone and approach arguments in good faith.
= Patient Discourse: Give ample time for responses; avoid overwhelming others. =
'''Patient Discourse''': Allow ample time for responses; avoid overwhelming others with rapid-fire arguments.
= Focus on Arguments: Refrain from personal attacks and ad hominem. =
'''Focus on Arguments''': Refrain from personal attacks and ad hominem tactics.
= Avoid Escalating Comparisons: Steer clear of extreme analogies like Godwin’s Law =
'''Avoid Escalating Comparisons''': Steer clear of extreme analogies or comparisons, such as invoking Godwin's Law. 
= Fact-Based Discussion: Back your arguments with facts and evidence. =
'''Fact-Based Discussion''': Support your arguments with facts, sources, and evidence wherever possible.
= Spectators: May ask respectful questions but cannot present arguments =
'''Spectators''': Spectators may ask respectful questions but cannot present arguments or take sides.


<span id="opening-prompt"></span>
== Opening Prompt ==
=== Opening Prompt ===


<pre class="debate-prompt">1. State Your Initial Position: Brief and Clear. Max Two Sentences.  
Use this structured prompt to start a debate and define sides clearly:
2. Create an Ephemeral Notepad and Post the Link: https://url.irregular.chat/debate-template
 
3. Open the Floor for Questions and join Sides from ALL.
<pre class="debate-prompt">
4. 10-Minute Argument Submission: post your argument Supporting your position.
1. State Your Initial Position: Keep it brief and clear. Maximum of two sentences.
5. Sides are defined. Only participants can ask questions beyond this point.  
2. Create an Ephemeral Notepad and Post the Link: Use https://cryptpad.irregularchat.com/pad/#/2/pad/view/+Hi8ffnuvn+ULb5FfNVSTKfiBiDX02d0Hylx7YHxxHo
3. Open the Floor for Questions and Side Selection: Invite participants to join sides.
4. 10-Minute Argument Submission: Post your initial argument supporting your position.
5. Sides Are Defined: Only participants can ask further questions once positions are set.
6. Respectful Debate:
6. Respectful Debate:
     •   Provide emoji to show support, questions, and objection
     • Use emoji reactions to show support, ask questions, or express objections.
     •   Only those with a stated position may make arguments. All can ask questions that can be direct but may be answered by either party.
     • Only those with a stated position may argue, though all may ask clarifying questions.
     •   Each side will then engage in a constructive and respectful debate.
     • Engage in a constructive, respectful debate focused on the arguments.
Let’s rumble!</pre>
Let's rumble!
<span id="setting-up-an-ephemeral-notepad"></span>
</pre>
=== Setting Up an Ephemeral Notepad ===
 
== Setting Up an Ephemeral Notepad ==
 
1. Open the debate template here: [https://cryptpad.irregularchat.com/pad/#/2/pad/view/+Hi8ffnuvn+ULb5FfNVSTKfiBiDX02d0Hylx7YHxxHo/ Cryptpad Debate Template].
2. Go to ''File > Copy'' to create a new, editable version of the notepad.
3. Share the URL with edit access in the debate chat so participants can join.


''File &gt; Copy'' of the template here: https://cryptpad.irregularchat.com/pad/#/2/pad/view/+Hi8ffnuvn+ULb5FfNVSTKfiBiDX02d0Hylx7YHxxHo/
== Debate Template ==


Then, paste the URL with edit access to the debate chat.
Use the following embedded template to facilitate the debate process:


<span id="debate-template"></span>
https://cryptpad.irregularchat.com/pad/#/2/pad/view/+Hi8ffnuvn+ULb5FfNVSTKfiBiDX02d0Hylx7YHxxHo/embed/
=== Debate Template ===


<iframe src="https://cryptpad.irregularchat.com/pad/#/2/pad/view/+Hi8ffnuvn+ULb5FfNVSTKfiBiDX02d0Hylx7YHxxHo/embed/" style="width: 100%; height: 1000px; border: none; overflow: hidden;">
== Categories ==
</iframe>
[[Category:Debate]]
[[Category:Community]]
[[Category:Discussion Rules]]
[[Category:Irregularchat]]
Retrieved from "https://irregularpedia.org/index.php/Debate"